Homework Part 1 of 3 Points: 0 of 2 Save Explain what is meant by confounding. What is a lurking variable? What is a confounding variable? What is meant by confounding? A. Confounding in a study occurs when the effects of the explanatory variable are caused, in some part, by the effects of the response variable. When there is zero confounding in a study, the effects of the response variable are entirely caused by the effects of the explanatory variable. B. Confounding in a study occurs when there is little or no actual relationship between the explanatory and response variable other than random chance. This sometimes causes completely unrelated variables to appear to have a causal relationship, and can cause variables that have almost no relationship to have a very strong relationship. C. Confounding in a study occurs when a single explanatory variable has a great effect on a response variable. This sometimes causes a misleading interpretation of the relationship between the two variables. D. Confounding in a study occurs when the effects of two or more explanatory variables are not separated. Therefore, any relation that may exist between an explanatory variable and the response variable may be due to some other variable or variables not accounted for in the study.

Question

UpStudy AI · Accepted Answer

Confounding is a fundamental concept in statistics and research design that can significantly impact the validity of study results. Let's break down the key terms and then address the multiple-choice question.

### **1. What is Confounding?**
**Confounding** occurs when the effect of the primary explanatory (independent) variable on the response (dependent) variable is mixed with the effect of another variable. This other variable, known as a **confounder**, is associated with both the explanatory and response variables but is not the focus of the study. Confounding can lead to misleading conclusions about the relationship between the variables of interest.

**Example:** 
Suppose a study finds that people who exercise more are healthier. However, if age is not accounted for, and younger individuals both exercise more and are generally healthier, age becomes a confounder. The apparent effect of exercise on health might actually be partly or entirely due to age.

### **2. What is a Lurking Variable?**
A **lurking variable** is similar to a confounder but is not included as an explanatory or response variable in the study. It remains hidden and can obscure the true relationship between the variables being studied.

**Example:**
In a study examining the relationship between ice cream sales and drowning incidents, a lurking variable could be **temperature**. Higher temperatures may lead to increased ice cream consumption and more people swimming, thereby increasing the likelihood of drowning incidents.

### **3. What is a Confounding Variable?**
A **confounding variable** is a specific type of lurking variable that is related to both the explanatory and response variables. It can distort the perceived relationship between these variables if not properly controlled or accounted for in the study design.

**Example:**
Continuing with the exercise example, **diet** could be a confounding variable. People who exercise regularly might also maintain healthier diets, which contributes to their overall health. If diet is not controlled for, the study may incorrectly attribute all health benefits to exercise alone.

---

### **Multiple-Choice Question Analysis**

**Question:** *What is meant by confounding?*

**Options:**
- **A.** Confounding in a study occurs when the effects of the explanatory variable are caused, in some part, by the effects of the response variable. When there is zero confounding in a study, the effects of the response variable are entirely caused by the effects of the explanatory variable.
  
  *Incorrect.* This option confuses the direction of causality, suggesting that the response variable affects the explanatory variable, which is not the case in confounding.

- **B.** Confounding in a study occurs when there is little or no actual relationship between the explanatory and response variable other than random chance. This sometimes causes completely unrelated variables to appear to have a causal relationship, and can cause variables that have almost no relationship to have a very strong relationship.
  
  *Partially Incorrect.* While it touches on the idea of misleading relationships, it doesn't accurately capture the role of a confounding variable that is related to both the explanatory and response variables.

- **C.** Confounding in a study occurs when a single explanatory variable has a great effect on a response variable. This sometimes causes a misleading interpretation of the relationship between the two variables.
  
  *Incorrect.* This option describes a strong relationship but doesn't address the presence of an additional variable that confounds the relationship.

- **D.** Confounding in a study occurs when the effects of two or more explanatory variables are not separated. Therefore, any relation that may exist between an explanatory variable and the response variable may be due to some other variable or variables not accounted for in the study.
  
  *Correct.* This accurately describes confounding by highlighting the interplay of multiple explanatory variables and the potential for unaccounted variables to distort the perceived relationship.

### **Conclusion**

**Option D** is the most accurate definition of confounding among the provided choices. It correctly identifies that confounding arises when multiple explanatory variables' effects are not separated, leading to potential misattribution of the relationship between the explanatory and response variables.
Confounding occurs when the effect of one variable on another is mixed with the effect of a third variable that is related to both. This can make it difficult to determine the true relationship between the variables being studied.

Solución de tutoría real

Responder

Solución

Mind Expander

preguntas relacionadas

Latest Statistics Questions