Student: "The wishes of students are completely ignored when it is decided which classes and activities are going to be offered. Students should be consulted and have input in the process. According to our survey, only \( 40 \% \) of students are happy with the currént situation." Teacher: "I understand your concern. But teachers are the ones who should have more say about curriculum. Teachers can be assigned classes without explanation, and they have no control over what they teach. Also, their opinions about grading are completely ignored." Use the passage to answer the question. that red herring fallacy is included in this paragraph? the wish of the student to have more input about the teacher's opinions about grading the data provided from the survey the teacher's acknowledgment of the student's concern
Solución de tutoría real
Responder
Solución
¡Inicia sesión para desbloquear respuestas gratis!
Una plataforma de aprendizaje en la que confían millones de estudiantes y profesores reales.
Descubrir Revisado y aprobado por el equipo de tutoría de UpStudy
Beyond the Answer
In this exchange, the teacher shifts the focus from the student's legitimate concern about input in class offerings to the issues teachers face, which is unrelated to the student's request. This diversion from the main argument is a classic case of the red herring fallacy. Instead of addressing the student’s plea for greater involvement, the teacher highlights the challenges teachers encounter, which distracts from the crux of the discussion. The survey data revealing that only 40% of students are satisfied showcases a clear disconnect between student needs and the current curriculum decisions. Highlighting this dissatisfaction illustrates the necessity of student input further, underpinning the argument for a more inclusive decision-making process in school activities and classes.
