4. Describe the Meselson and Stahl experiments in details. 3. What would be the outcome if the experiment continued for: i. three generations ii. four generations iii. five generations

Question

UpStudy AI · Accepted Answer

### **4. Description of the Meselson and Stahl Experiments**

The Meselson and Stahl experiments, conducted in 1958 by Matthew Meselson and Franklin Stahl, are renowned for providing definitive evidence supporting the semi-conservative model of DNA replication. Their work elegantly demonstrated how DNA replicates, addressing a fundamental question in molecular biology: *How is genetic information accurately passed from one generation to the next?*

#### **Background Context**

Before Meselson and Stahl's experiments, three models of DNA replication were proposed:

1. **Conservative Model:** The original DNA molecule remains intact, and an entirely new double-stranded DNA molecule is synthesized.
2. **Semi-Conservative Model:** Each of the two original DNA strands serves as a template for new strands, resulting in two DNA molecules each containing one old and one new strand.
3. **Dispersive Model:** The DNA is broken into pieces, and each new DNA molecule contains a mixture of old and new DNA segments.

The prevailing question was determining which of these models accurately describes the process of DNA replication in vivo.

#### **Experimental Design**

Meselson and Stahl employed a clever experimental approach using *Escherichia coli* (E. coli) bacteria and isotopic labeling with nitrogen isotopes to distinguish between old and new DNA strands.

1. **Isotopic Labeling with Nitrogen Isotopes:**
   - **^15N:** A heavy isotope of nitrogen with an atomic mass of approximately 15.
   - **^14N:** The lighter, more common nitrogen isotope with an atomic mass of approximately 14.

DNA contains nitrogen as a component of its nucleotide bases. By growing bacteria in a medium containing ^15N, the bacteria incorporate this heavy nitrogen into their DNA, making the DNA denser.

2. **Generation of ^15N-Labeled DNA:**
   - E. coli were first grown in a medium containing ^15N for several generations, ensuring all DNA was fully labeled with the heavy isotope (^15N-DNA).

3. **Density Gradient Centrifugation:**
   - DNA samples were placed in a cesium chloride (CsCl) solution and subjected to ultracentrifugation, forming a density gradient where DNA molecules band at positions corresponding to their densities.

4. **Switching to a ^14N Medium:**
   - After establishing ^15N-labeled DNA, Meselson and Stahl shifted the bacteria to a medium containing only ^14N. This ensured that any new DNA synthesized would incorporate the lighter ^14N isotope.

5. **Sampling at Successive Generations:**
   - They extracted DNA at various time points corresponding to successive generations of bacterial growth, allowing them to analyze the distribution of DNA densities after replication events.

#### **Key Findings**

1. **First Generation After Shift to ^14N:**
   - The density of DNA measured was **intermediate** between ^15N-DNA and ^14N-DNA. This suggested that each DNA molecule consisted of one old (heavy) strand and one new (light) strand, supporting the semi-conservative model.

2. **Second Generation:**
   - Upon further replication, two distinct DNA densities were observed:
     - **Light DNA (^14N/^14N):** Newly synthesized DNA with both strands containing ^14N.
     - **Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N):** Each molecule still had one old ^15N strand and one newly synthesized ^14N strand.
   
   This pattern eliminated the conservative model (which would predict both entirely heavy and entirely light DNA) and the dispersive model (which would predict a single intermediate density).

3. **Subsequent Generations:**
   - As generations progressed, the proportion of light DNA increased while the intermediate density DNA remained constant, further corroborating the semi-conservative mechanism.

#### **Conclusion**

The Meselson and Stahl experiments provided strong empirical support for the semi-conservative model of DNA replication. Their meticulous use of isotopic labeling and density gradient centrifugation effectively distinguished between the proposed replication models, solidifying our understanding of genetic information transmission.

### **3. Predicted Outcomes if the Experiment Continued for Additional Generations**

Building upon Meselson and Stahl's experimental framework, let's explore the expected DNA density distribution in the third, fourth, and fifth generations after the bacterial shift to a ^14N medium, assuming continued semi-conservative replication.

#### **i. Three Generations**

- **Generation 0 (Parental):** 100% Heavy DNA (^15N/^15N)
- **Generation 1:** 100% Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N)
- **Generation 2:** 50% Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N) and 50% Light DNA (^14N/^14N)
- **Generation 3:**
  - **From Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N):** Each molecule produces one intermediate (^15N/^14N) and one light (^14N/^14N) DNA molecule.
  - **From Light DNA (^14N/^14N):** Each molecule produces two light (^14N/^14N) DNA molecules.
  
  **Expected Distribution:**
  - **25% Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N)**
  - **75% Light DNA (^14N/^14N)**

#### **ii. Four Generations**

Continuing the semi-conservative replication:

- **Generation 4:**
  - **From Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N):** Each produces one intermediate (^15N/^14N) and one light (^14N/^14N) DNA molecule.
  - **From Light DNA (^14N/^14N):** Each produces two light (^14N/^14N) DNA molecules.

Calculation based on Generation 3:
  - **25% Intermediate DNA:**
    - Yields 25% Intermediate + 25% Light
  - **75% Light DNA:**
    - Yields 75% Light + 75% Light

**Total:**
  - **12.5% Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N)**
  - **87.5% Light DNA (^14N/^14N)**

#### **iii. Five Generations**

Extending to the fifth generation:

- **Generation 5:**
  - **From Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N):** Each produces one intermediate (^15N/^14N) and one light (^14N/^14N) DNA molecule.
  - **From Light DNA (^14N/^14N):** Each produces two light (^14N/^14N) DNA molecules.

Calculation based on Generation 4:
  - **12.5% Intermediate DNA:**
    - Yields 12.5% Intermediate + 12.5% Light
  - **87.5% Light DNA:**
    - Yields 87.5% Light + 87.5% Light

**Total:**
  - **6.25% Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N)**
  - **93.75% Light DNA (^14N/^14N)**

#### **Summary of Predicted Outcomes:**

| Generation | Intermediate DNA (^15N/^14N) | Light DNA (^14N/^14N) |
|------------|-------------------------------|-----------------------|
| 1          | 100%                          | 0%                    |
| 2          | 50%                           | 50%                   |
| 3          | 25%                           | 75%                   |
| 4          | 12.5%                         | 87.5%                 |
| 5          | 6.25%                         | 93.75%                |

#### **Interpretation**

As generations progress:

- **Proportion of Intermediate DNA Decreases:** Each generation halves the proportion of intermediate (^15N/^14N) DNA as one strand from each intermediate molecule contributes to new light (^14N/^14N) DNA.
  
- **Proportion of Light DNA Increases:** With each generation, more DNA molecules consist entirely of ^14N due to the continuous synthesis of new light strands.

- **Long-Term Trend:** The system asymptotically approaches 100% light (^14N/^14N) DNA after numerous generations, reflecting the complete replacement of the original heavy (^15N) strands with light strands through semi-conservative replication.

This progression effectively demonstrates the predictability and consistency of the semi-conservative replication mechanism, reinforcing the conclusions drawn from the original Meselson and Stahl experiments.
Meselson and Stahl's experiments used nitrogen isotopes to show that DNA replicates semi-conservatively, producing one old and one new strand per DNA molecule. After shifting bacteria to a lighter nitrogen source, they observed intermediate and light DNA densities in successive generations. - **After 1 generation:** 100% intermediate DNA. - **After 2 generations:** 50% intermediate and 50% light DNA. - **After 3 generations:** 25% intermediate and 75% light DNA. - **After 4 generations:** 12.5% intermediate and 87.5% light DNA. - **After 5 generations:** 6.25% intermediate and 93.75% light DNA. This pattern shows that with each generation, the proportion of intermediate DNA decreases while light DNA increases, confirming the semi-conservative model of DNA replication.

4. Describe the Meselson and Stahl experiments in details. 3. What would be the outcome if the experiment continued for: i. three generations ii. four generations iii. five generations

Real Tutor Solution

Answer

Solution

Beyond the Answer

Related Questions

Latest Biology Questions