Question
Questions about Mulan (2020):
- We discussed the depiction of gender in the animated version
of Mulan (1998) earlier in the semester; explore the depiction
of gender in the 2020 version.
- Identify 3 central differences between the animated version
(1998) and the live-action version (2020). Comment on
whether you think each change is a positive or negative
change. What, if anything, did the remake gain? What, if
anything, did it lose?
- Explore some general differences between animation and live
action: are e they too different to fruitfully compare? Or can a
meaningful comparison be made?
- Identify anything that was problematic to you in the remake.
of Mulan (1998) earlier in the semester; explore the depiction
of gender in the 2020 version.
(1998) and the live-action version (2020). Comment on
whether you think each change is a positive or negative
change. What, if anything, did the remake gain? What, if
anything, did it lose?
action: are e they too different to fruitfully compare? Or can a
meaningful comparison be made?
Ask by Chan Huang. in the United States
Dec 12,2024
Upstudy AI Solution
Tutor-Verified Answer
Answer
The 2020 live-action Mulan offers a more serious and culturally grounded portrayal of gender compared to the animated version. It introduces new characters and themes but faces criticism for character development and cultural representation. The film’s pacing and structure have also been criticized.
Solution

Sign in to Unlock Answers for Free!
A Learning Platform Trusted by Millions of Real Students and Teachers.

Answered by UpStudy AI and reviewed by a Professional Tutor
Like
Beyond the Answer
In the live-action Mulan (2020), the portrayal of gender shifts to highlight strength and honor over romantic interests. Mulan is depicted as a warrior first and foremost, showcasing her skills and resilience. The film emphasizes empowerment and self-acceptance, moving away from traditional gender roles while also exploring themes of familial duty. This focus on internal strength rather than just defiance of norms presents a modern interpretation of the character.
Three notable differences include Mulan’s character arc, the absence of musical elements, and the introduction of new characters like Xianniang, a witch. The shift from musical to a serious narrative can be viewed as a positive, adding depth, while some argue it loses the charm and lightheartedness of the animated classic. Overall, the remake gains a more mature storytelling approach, but loses the whimsical spirit that defined the original.