Question
Many historians consider the Articles of Confederation as a flawed form of government.
Which of the following choices would best represent possible fixes to the document? (Chec
all that apply.)
Allow changes with a
Create an executive advisory committee
Allow Congress to collect taxes
Allow states to declare war
Which of the following choices would best represent possible fixes to the document? (Chec
all that apply.)
Allow changes with a
Create an executive advisory committee
Allow Congress to collect taxes
Allow states to declare war
Ask by Harper Howell. in the United States
Jan 25,2025
Upstudy AI Solution
Tutor-Verified Answer
Answer
The best fixes are:
- Allow changes with a
vote - Create an executive advisory committee
- Allow Congress to collect taxes
Solution
The Articles of Confederation had several significant weaknesses that limited the effectiveness of the national government. Here’s how the proposed fixes address these issues:
-
Allow changes with a
rds vote: - Explanation: Under the Articles of Confederation, amendments required the unanimous consent of all 13 states, making it extremely difficult to implement necessary changes. Lowering the threshold to a two-thirds majority would make it easier to adapt and improve the governing framework.
- Relevance: Yes, this would be a beneficial fix.
-
Create an executive advisory committee:
- Explanation: The Articles of Confederation lacked an executive branch to enforce laws and provide leadership. Establishing an executive advisory committee would help in the administration and implementation of laws passed by Congress.
- Relevance: Yes, this would address the lack of a centralized executive authority.
-
Allow Congress to collect taxes:
- Explanation: One of the major flaws of the Articles was that Congress did not have the power to levy taxes, making it financially dependent on the states and unable to sustain national needs effectively. Granting Congress the power to collect taxes would provide a stable revenue source.
- Relevance: Yes, this would strengthen the financial capabilities of the national government.
-
Allow states to declare war:
- Explanation: Granting states the power to declare war would further fragment national authority and could lead to inconsistencies and conflicts in national defense strategies. Instead, ensuring that Congress has sole authority to declare war would maintain a unified national defense.
- Relevance: No, this would not be a beneficial fix and could exacerbate the fragmentation issues inherent in the Articles.
Best Choices for Fixes:
- Allow changes with a
rds vote - Create an executive advisory committee
- Allow Congress to collect taxes
Not Recommended:
- Allow states to declare war
Answered by UpStudy AI and reviewed by a Professional Tutor
Like
error msg
Explain 
Simplify this solution Beyond the Answer
The Articles of Confederation, ratified in 1781, struggled to unify the states under a central government due to its weak framework. A key fix would be allowing Congress to collect taxes, which would provide essential revenue for the federal government, enabling it to pay debts and fund initiatives effectively. Additionally, a
In the real world, implementing these changes could have dramatically altered the course of American governance. The ability to collect taxes would have empowered the federal government to strengthen its legitimacy and avoid the financial difficulties that arose during and after the Revolutionary War. Furthermore, creating a central decision-making body with a capable framework for amendments could have led to a more stable political landscape, potentially reducing the chaos that followed the Articles’ implementation and paving the way for the successful adoption of the Constitution.
