Question
upstudy study bank question image url

joln and Sipho sit on the see-saw. John is the load and Sipho is the 1 joint. What do you think happens? Think about their weights. Will this lever be MA \( >1, \mathrm{MA}=1 \) or \( \mathrm{MA}<1 \) ? john stays on the see-saw and remains the load. Sipho gets off and peter gets on. Now the effort is heavier than the load. Meaning, more force has to be applied to move the load. Will this lever be \( \mathrm{MA}>1, \mathrm{MA}=1 \) or \( \mathrm{MA}<1 \) ? Finally, Peter gets off the see-saw while John is still on and he remains the load. Sureshin gets on and becomes the effort. The of the effort is smaller than the load, but Sureshin gives

Ask by Hodgson Watkins. in South Africa
Feb 03,2025

Real Tutor Solution

Tutor-Verified Answer

Answer

When John is the load on the see-saw: 1. **With Sipho as the fulcrum and an equal effort:** The lever is balanced (MA = 1). 2. **With Peter as the effort (heavier than John):** The lever has a mechanical disadvantage (MA < 1). 3. **With Sureshin as the effort (lighter than John):** The lever has a mechanical advantage (MA > 1). So, the **Mechanical Advantage (MA)** depends on the relative weights of the effort and the load: - **MA = 1** when effort equals load. - **MA < 1** when effort is greater than load. - **MA > 1** when effort is less than load.

Solution

Let's analyze each scenario involving John, Sipho, Peter, and Sureshin on the see-saw (acting as a lever). We'll determine the **Mechanical Advantage (MA)** in each case based on the weights (forces) involved. **Mechanical Advantage (MA)** in a lever system is defined as the ratio of the **Load Force** (weight to be moved) to the **Effort Force** (force applied to move the load): \[ \text{MA} = \frac{\text{Load Force}}{\text{Effort Force}} \] - **MA > 1**: The lever provides a mechanical advantage, meaning the effort force is less than the load force. - **MA = 1**: The lever is balanced; effort and load forces are equal. - **MA < 1**: The lever has a mechanical disadvantage, meaning the effort force is greater than the load force. Let's examine each scenario: --- ### **1. John as the Load and Sipho as the Joint (Fulcrum)** - **Scenario Description:** - **Load:** John remains on the see-saw. - **Fulcrum:** Sipho acts as the pivot point. - **Effort:** Not explicitly mentioned, but assuming another person (let's say Effortator) is applying force on the opposite side to balance or move the load. - **Analysis:** - Since the fulcrum is managed by Sipho and John is on one side, the position of the effort relative to the fulcrum will determine the MA. - **If Effortator applies a force equal to John's weight at an equal distance from the fulcrum:** - **MA = 1** (Balanced see-saw). - **If Effortator applies a force greater or lesser than John's weight or at different distances:** - **MA > 1 or MA < 1** accordingly. - **Conclusion:** - **Without specific weights and distances,** it's likely that if they're simply sitting symmetrically, **MA ≈ 1**. --- ### **2. John as the Load and Peter as the Effort (Sipho Off the See-Saw)** - **Scenario Description:** - **Load:** John remains on the see-saw. - **Effort:** Peter joins, and his weight is **heavier than John's**. - **Fulcrum:** Remains unchanged (assuming central position). - **Analysis:** - **Effort Force > Load Force** (Peter is heavier than John). - **MA = Load / Effort < 1** because the effort needed is greater to lift or balance the load. - **Implications:** - **Mechanical Disadvantage (MA < 1):** More effort is required to move or balance John's weight due to Peter's heavier effort force. - **Conclusion:** - **MA < 1** --- ### **3. John as the Load and Sureshin as the Effort (Peter Off the See-Saw)** - **Scenario Description:** - **Load:** John remains on the see-saw. - **Effort:** Sureshin joins, and his weight is **less than John's**. - **Fulcrum:** Remains unchanged. - **Analysis:** - **Effort Force < Load Force** (Sureshin is lighter than John). - **MA = Load / Effort > 1** because less effort is needed to lift a heavier load. - **Implications:** - **Mechanical Advantage (MA > 1):** Sureshin can lift or balance John's weight more easily, possibly by applying less force over a longer distance or through leveraging arms. - **Conclusion:** - **MA > 1** --- ### **Summary Table** | **Scenario** | **Load** | **Effort** | **MA** | |---------------------------------------------|----------|------------|----------| | John as Load, Effort Equal (Balanced) | John | Equal to John | **= 1** | | John as Load, Peter (Heavier Effort) | John | Peter (heavier) | **< 1** | | John as Load, Sureshin (Lighter Effort) | John | Sureshin (lighter) | **> 1** | --- ### **Key Takeaways** 1. **Balanced Lever (MA = 1):** When effort and load forces are equal and applied at equal distances from the fulcrum, the lever remains balanced. 2. **Mechanical Disadvantage (MA < 1):** When the effort force is greater than the load force, more effort is needed to move the load. 3. **Mechanical Advantage (MA > 1):** When the effort force is less than the load force, less effort is required to move a heavier load, which is advantageous for lifting or balancing heavy objects with minimal effort. Understanding the **Mechanical Advantage** helps in designing systems that optimize force usage, making tasks easier based on the lever's configuration.

Reviewed and approved by the UpStudy tutoring team

error msg
Explain
Simplify this solution

The Deep Dive

When John and Sipho are on the see-saw, with John as the load and Sipho acting as the effort, the mechanical advantage (MA) can be analyzed by looking at their weights and the distances from the pivot. If Sipho is lighter and seated further from the pivot, the MA will likely be greater than 1. This means Sipho can lift John even if he weighs more because of the distance leverage! Now, when Sipho gets off and Peter takes his place with a heavier weight, the dynamic changes. If Peter's weight exceeds John's, the force required to lift John increases, indicating that the MA will be less than 1. It means more effort is needed to move the load, showing that the see-saw is not favoring the effort side anymore.

Related Questions

Latest Physics Questions

Try Premium now!
Try Premium and ask Thoth AI unlimited math questions now!
Maybe later Go Premium
Study can be a real struggle
Why not UpStudy it?
Select your plan below
Premium

You can enjoy

Start now
  • Step-by-step explanations
  • 24/7 expert live tutors
  • Unlimited number of questions
  • No interruptions
  • Full access to Answer and Solution
  • Full Access to PDF Chat, UpStudy Chat, Browsing Chat
Basic

Totally free but limited

  • Limited Solution
Welcome to UpStudy!
Please sign in to continue the Thoth AI Chat journey
Continue with Email
Or continue with
By clicking “Sign in”, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy