Pregunta
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed
by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the
pursuit of Happiness. "Thomas Jefferson (1787)
Who would agree with the above quote: Locke or Hobbes? Explain:
by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the
pursuit of Happiness. "Thomas Jefferson (1787)
Who would agree with the above quote: Locke or Hobbes? Explain:
Ask by Chavez Lang. in the United States
Jan 29,2025
Solución de tutoría real
Respuesta verificada por el tutor
Responder
Thomas Jefferson’s quote aligns with John Locke’s philosophy, emphasizing natural rights and equality, rather than Thomas Hobbes’s more authoritarian views.
Solución
The quote attributed to Thomas Jefferson emphasizes foundational principles such as equality, natural rights (Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness), and the inherent dignity bestowed by a Creator. These ideas are closely aligned with the philosophy of John Locke rather than Thomas Hobbes. Here’s why:
John Locke’s Alignment with the Quote
-
Natural Rights:
- Locke’s View: Locke was a strong proponent of natural rights, which he believed were inherent to all individuals by virtue of their humanity. These rights include life, liberty, and property.
- Quote Connection: The mention of “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” mirrors Locke’s emphasis on natural rights that governments are created to protect.
-
State of Nature and Equality:
- Locke’s View: Locke viewed the state of nature as a state of equality and freedom, where individuals are equal and independent, with the ability to govern themselves through reason.
- Quote Connection: The assertion that “all men are created equal” reflects Locke’s belief in the fundamental equality of all individuals.
-
Government by Consent:
- Locke’s View: He advocated for a government that exists with the consent of the governed, primarily to protect their natural rights.
- Quote Connection: The idea that rights are “unalienable” suggests that governments derive their legitimacy from respecting and safeguarding these inherent rights, aligning with Locke’s principles.
Contrast with Thomas Hobbes
-
View of Human Nature:
- Hobbes’s View: Hobbes had a more pessimistic view of human nature, believing that in the absence of a strong central authority, life would be “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.”
- Quote Contrast: The optimistic tone of the quote, focusing on inherent rights and equality, contrasts sharply with Hobbes’s belief in the necessity of absolute sovereignty to maintain order.
-
Purpose of Government:
- Hobbes’s View: For Hobbes, the primary role of government is to impose order and prevent the chaos of the state of nature through absolute authority.
- Quote Contrast: The emphasis on natural rights and equality suggests a government that protects individual freedoms rather than one that wields absolute power, which is contrary to Hobbes’s philosophy.
Conclusion
The principles articulated in the quote—natural equality, inherent rights, and the pursuit of happiness—are quintessentially Lockean. John Locke’s theories on natural rights and government by consent directly support the sentiments expressed, making him the philosopher who would agree with the statement. In contrast, Thomas Hobbes’s emphasis on absolute authority and his more cynical view of human nature stand in opposition to the ideals presented in the quote.
Revisado y aprobado por el equipo de tutoría de UpStudy
Como
error msg
![](/pmw/light_bulb.png?etag=525fd69ac661e11754e2fc9f1b18a4ee)
![](/pmw/spiral_notepad.png?etag=abe3906b7558c543a7b30ba53a3b5a5b)
The Deep Dive
Locke would wholeheartedly agree with Jefferson’s quote, as both philosophers emphasize the importance of individual rights and the idea that people are born with inherent freedoms. Locke’s notion of natural rights, including life, liberty, and property, directly aligns with Jefferson’s assertion that these rights are self-evident and granted by a higher power. In contrast, Hobbes believes in a strong central authority to maintain order, suggesting that individuals surrender their rights for security, which contradicts Jefferson’s ideas of equality and unalienable rights.
If Hobbes were to comment on this quote, he might argue that such ideals could lead to chaos without a governing authority to enforce peace. He prioritizes social order over individual liberty, viewing the human condition as one that leans toward self-interest and conflict. Thus, Hobbes would likely advocate for a more controlled environment where personal liberties are limited for the sake of safety and order.
![](/pmw/img-try-permium.webp)
¡Prueba Premium ahora!
¡Prueba Premium y hazle a Thoth AI preguntas de matemáticas ilimitadas ahora!
Quizas mas tarde
Hazte Premium